Keen Home  | Blog Policies  | Help
Welcome to Community Sign in | Join | Help

My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

   
I have a particular situation involving a friend of mine. Recently, she confided in me that she is absolutely torn - her best friend hates, despises, and constantly criticizes her boyfriend. She doesn't want to lose either one of them, but both are forcing her to continually make decisions which put her in the position to choose between them. Hunh?

How does one choose a best friend over a love life?

The arguments that occur are centered on either the best friend or the boyfriend, depending upon who she is with. The best friend tells her that her boyfriend is controlling, abusive, and destroying her life (whose life is she talking about, I wonder). Of course, the boyfriend tells her the same thing that her best friend is controlling, abusive, and a negative influence.

What to do? I suggested that she stop the insanity, and tell them both to go duke it out in a dark ally. IF her best friend truly cared for her, she wouldn't put her in this position. Likewise for the boyfriend. So what if neither like each other?

I feel that the bottom line is fear - he is fearful that this girlfriend/best friend is going to influence his girlfriend to the point where she will listen and eventually dump him. The 'best friend' is fearful that she will lose her friend, and not have anyone to pal around with. Both of these people have control issues and are using this woman in a tug of war, just to trump each other.

It is a sad situation, but can it be resolved so that (in the infamous words of Rodney King) they can all just get along? It's not a matter of who is more important than whom. She loves her boyfriend and her best friend equally (although differently). So why, I ask myself, is this woman being put in a position to choose? Both are making unreasonable demands on her.

My solution was for them all to sit down and have a "Come to Jesus" talk, get it all out in the open and try to resolve the issues. If that doesn't work, then what? If it were ME, I told this woman that maybe neither of these people are nurturing her growth and perhaps it was time to move forward with her life. That didn't sit well, either, because then the choice she was forced to make was dump them both.

Sometimes, life hands us challenges that - unfortunately, we do have to make choices that are difficult, but ultimately better for our growth.

**************
I'm available for your calls today
and hope you have a Fabulous Wednesday!
Sending you angels,
Jane


Published Wednesday, August 29, 2007 8:43 AM by Jane Wilcox
Filed Under:

Comment Notification

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

Wednesday, August 29, 2007 7:33 PM by haines10

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

just in case you havent noticed...you spell "destroy" with an "e"....lol.....sorry...it screamed at me...lol.....but good advice as usual!
it kills me to be back at school...
Thursday, August 30, 2007 6:03 AM by Jane Wilcox

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

LOL - you school teacher types! AAAK Where's spellchecker when it's needed? Don't you hate it when you look at a word and you know it's wrong, but not sure how to correct it? Sorta like some relationships....
Saturday, April 19, 2008 9:42 PM by fred

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

well my best friends boyfriend is a perv who has recently "changed" in the last two weeks. and i do not like him at all. i told her that and she wants me to hang out with them, i have never liked this kid and she says that she cant help who she likes, what am i supposed to do?
Monday, April 21, 2008 1:17 PM by Jane Wilcox

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

Well, Fred, what you do is politely decline telling your friend that if she chooses to hang with this guy that you will hang with her when she isn't with him. Don't put her in a position of having to choose one over the other - you can empower yourself by simply drawing your own boundaries, and stating that you prefer not to be around this guy. Simple?
Saturday, June 21, 2008 6:51 AM by samantha

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

i think friends get jelious when your not with them. my bestfriend is treating my boyfriend like crap. he has never done anything wrong to her.  he likes her as a friend and she hates his guts. but she never tells me any reasons why she hates him. she pushes him around and calls him names and he doesnt like it. i dont know what to do :S ????
Friday, November 07, 2008 2:50 PM by Ashley

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

You should never have to choose between your bestfriend and you're boyfriend, it should never come to that.
Friday, November 07, 2008 5:42 PM by Jane Wilcox

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

And YOU, Ashley, are ABSOLUTELY RIGHT! A "Best friend" would never put you in that position!
Wednesday, April 15, 2009 7:30 PM by Crystal

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

I know it sounds bad...  I love my best friend dearly but if you really love you man, you'll always stick to your man.  If its a true best friend they will understand.  I'm not saying push your best friend out of your life, but when your in a serious adult relationship, you have got to put your priorities straight.
Thursday, April 30, 2009 12:15 PM by Rosemary

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

Well i really like this guy and he doesnt have the best past or criminal background but he's a sweetheart to me and really who am i to judge someone ya know? well anywayz my best friend absolutely hates him so much and i really dont understand why, me and my best friend just recently moved in together and she's okay with ruining her credit but i am not okay with ruining mine. if i dont break it off with him she's moving out and then we're gonna get sued for breaking a lease and i dont have any reason to break up with my boyfriend and honestly i dont really want to but i feel like i have to choose and it's tearing me apart...what do i do?
Friday, May 01, 2009 8:19 AM by Jane Wilcox

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

Rosemary, this situation requires you to "be the adult". Tell her that if she moves out, you're stuck. She made a commitment - on paper - that she'd hold the lease with you. Tell her that you will not bring your BF around her. You will have to sacrifice, and so will she. (Gee, kinda like a marriage)....
Saturday, May 02, 2009 3:05 PM by Sam

# Wondering

I'm dating this guy and my mother doesn't like him. She says if I stay with him that I can't have him around for family events. She's not thrilled that I wanna be with him, even though she hates him. I'm almost 21 and I don't live with her but still respect her decisions always. This one I'm confused about. What should i do?
Saturday, May 02, 2009 3:21 PM by Jane Wilcox

# re: My Best Friend Hates My Boyfriend

Sam, Clearly it's not fair of your mother to do this to you; you can't really boycott family events, so you go to them, stay a bit then leave to go be with your BF. She must have a reason for not liking him...And maybe she can see something in him that you're turning a blind eye to - maybe try and see what she sees that you don't....?

What do you think?

(required) 
(required) 
(required) 
Enter the numbers you see into the
field below.
(required)